Nantucket Grill

Not available.

Adam Wallace

The Nantucket Grill in Durham offers a dining experience steeped in New England tradition, featuring a sprawling menu of seafood, steaks, and classic American dishes. However, what truly defines a visit here isn't the entree—it's the infamous, sky-high, multi-layer cakes displayed prominently upon entry. ​The Atmosphere and Service ​Nantucket Grill leans into a classic, established ambiance, which some may find charmingly old-school, while others might view it as slightly dated. The setting is generally comfortable, with outdoor seating often available. ​The menu is extensive, offering everything from Filet Mignon and Cajun Ribeye to New England staples like the Maine Lobster Roll, Crab Cakes, and various stuffed seafood preparations (like the Nantucket Island Stuffed Tilapia). Popular savory choices include the Atlantic Grilled Salmon and the Jambalaya Pasta, which is described as a flavorful, zesty Creole dish. For lunch, the French Dip sandwich and the Blackened Salmon Salad are reliable options. ​If there is one non-negotiable reason to visit Nantucket Grill, it is for the bakery case. The restaurant is universally known for its massive, multi-layered cakes—truly impressive feats of pastry engineering. The favorites are consistently the Strawberry Shortcake (often cited as the best) and the Coconut Vanilla Cake (Coconut Cloud). ​The cakes are decadent, moist, and enormous; a single slice is often substantial enough to serve two or three people. Many regulars opt for sandwiches or salads for their meal just to save room for this signature dessert, or simply stop by for a slice to take home. ​Nantucket Grill is an institution that successfully serves a niche. It is the perfect choice for family dinners, those craving classic New England comfort food, or anyone who values a spectacular dessert above all else. Just make sure you save room for it!

Awsum Davis

We ordered the crab dip, but it had a very fishy taste. The manager was understanding and removed it from the ticket, and we replaced it with the spinach dip. Unfortunately, we didn’t enjoy that dish either. When we asked about removing it, the manager said only one item could be taken off, which was disappointing and didn’t make much sense. The seafood pasta also wasn’t enjoyable, as it had far too many tomatoes. The one highlight was the steak, which was cooked well. The strawberry cake was yummy ! Overall, the experience was not satisfying, and I would not return.

Tiff Barnes

Ordered carryout from Nantucket Grill during my break at work not long ago. This was my first time ordering food from this restaurant. I have had their strawberry shortcake a couple times and it is absolutely delicious! I decided to try their Jambalaya Pasta and Unbirthday Cake. The pasta was good but the cake okay. It was a little dry on this day. I will return for the strawberry shortcake when I need something sweet!

michlith

The food, service, and atmosphere is amazing! Miguel was our server! He checked on us making sure we were happy. We watched Shawn handle a difficult table with politeness and ease! If you are looking for a place that is a hidden gem, THIS IS THE PLACE!