All Star Pizza

Not available.

Marissa Cohen

I headed to Frank Pepe’s to finish my workday and enjoy a nice lunch. I’ve been recommended the white clam pizza by dozens of people, and having always been a “plain Jane” pizza type, i decided to give it a try. While I’ll say it’s not my favorite, for some other people, it might be delicious. My server, Jeff came over to check up on me, and I told him I wasn’t a huge fan and that I’d like a plain tomato and mozzarella pizza (and said i would absolutely still pay for the clam pizza). He apologized and had them make me a new pizza. The manager (whose name I unfortunately did not catch) came over and asked me what happened. I told her it’s just not my taste but the second pizza was great. She asked if i needed anything else and I asked for a recommendation for dessert. She told me her favorite was the tiramisu but i decided on the caramel mascarpone cheesecake instead. She brought me both to see which I liked better and charged me for neither to make up for the pizza - which was not their fault. Both desserts were incredible and melted in my mouth 🤤 Then i got the bill and they had really taken care of me. It was such a lovely lunch. They were so kind and considerate. I will absolutely be back. The staff was amazing, food was delicious, and atmosphere was relaxing! 10/10

Louis Galdo

A great pizza dining experience. Unbelievable New Haven Apizza and service 5 stars. Dessert was great as well.

Xyon Smith

This place was amazing, the food was delicious, service was on point and that Soda 😋😋😋. I am not a soda person but I am changing that because of that Cream Soda that I try, amazing.

marc iannucci

Well this aint new haven pizza for sure. The service was ok but slow. The food surprisingly took over an hour to come to our table and the pizzas were undercooked. We even had a reservation. I dont understand how this could happen as there appeared to be a full staff working and they were busy. I would have to sadly say, hard pass. There are better places around or maybe connecticut just does it better at the original Pepes. Really disappointed. I had high hopes here