Duke of York

We walked into Library Bar at the Fairmont for a birthday celebration without a reservation and were told there’d be about a 10-minute wait — which was perfectly fine and definitely worth it. The moment we stepped inside, the atmosphere felt elegant yet cozy, with its dim lighting, plush seating, and that timeless Fairmont sophistication that makes the evening feel special from the start. Once seated, we ordered a few appetizers and paired them with a beautiful glass of wine. The menu isn’t extensive, but it’s clearly designed with care — every item feels intentional and high quality. We also tried some of their signature cocktails, which were creative, well-balanced, and beautifully presented. The entire experience — from the food to the drinks — felt refined and indulgent. Our server was wonderful: warm, professional, and genuinely attentive without ever feeling intrusive. The highlight of the night was when they surprised us with a crème brûlée topped with a candle and a handwritten “Happy Birthday” message. It was such a thoughtful touch that made the evening feel extra special. The total came to about $400 for the two of us, including drinks — certainly on the pricier side, but for the quality, service, and atmosphere, it felt justified. It’s not an everyday spot, but for a special occasion, it’s worth every dollar. Overall, Library Bar perfectly blends classic elegance with a relaxed, intimate feel. A beautiful choice for celebrations, quiet evenings, or simply enjoying good wine and conversation in one of Toronto’s most timeless settings.

We had the best Bay Street Sandwich aka roast beef sandwich. Since 1973 they have perfected this delicious meal. I would have to say one of the best I have ever had. Our waiter Rene was outstanding. He took the time to explain the history of the Library. While still delivering exceptional service. We recommend to try the tea. The cocktail list is one to explore!

This, IMHO, is one of the top 3 cocktail bars in the city. Been coming here for a few years now. The team is here is unmatched and is one of the main reasons I keep coming back. One note regarding the recent introduction of OpenTable reservations, consider leaving the limited bar seating for walk-ins only.